In this article
- What the CFTC chairman asked for
- How the Midwest premium aluminum CFTC review fits the current price stack
- Separating the benchmark from the scarcity
- Why the review also reaches scrap and recycled aluminum
- Two levers on the same cost: Section 232 and benchmark reform
- What buyers in Mexico can do with the Midwest premium review now
On November 13, CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig spoke at the Beer Institute’s annual membership meeting. He said he had directed his global markets team “to examine these pricing mechanisms and develop concrete reform options.” The mechanism in question is the Midwest premium, the regional surcharge added to the LME price in North American aluminum contracts. With that remark, the Midwest premium aluminum CFTC review puts the benchmark itself under regulatory scrutiny, not only its level (CFTC).
Nothing changes yet. Selig said the views were his own and not necessarily those of the Commission. In addition, the review has no published timeline (Vinetur). Contracts that price on LME plus Midwest work today exactly as they did last week.
Buyers in Mexico who fix price on that same formula face practical questions. They concern contract language for 2027 and the instruments that may exist by then. This article sets out what was said, how the premium is built today, and which scenarios remain open.
What the CFTC chairman asked for
Selig put three ideas on the table. First, he wants to evaluate “whether additional U.S.-based aluminum contracts could improve local price discovery.” Second, he mentioned “a U.S.-based contract tied to physical delivery in the American market.” Third, he raised the option to “develop a derivatives market structure specifically for recycled aluminum” (CFTC).
He also attached numbers to the problem. He cited an LME benchmark of around USD 1.40/lb and a Midwest premium near USD 1.10/lb, a figure he attributed to S&P Global Commodity Insights. Together, he said, the all-in US price sits around USD 2.50/lb. In other words, the regional premium is now worth most of the LME price itself.
The reaction from consumers was direct. Mary Jane Saunders, longtime general counsel of the Beer Institute, called the review “a big deal for us.” Critics of the current benchmark argue that storage, logistics, financing and market structure weigh on the premium, not only supply and demand (Vinetur). However, the Midwest premium aluminum CFTC review is a review, not a rule. The CFTC has not proposed any change to existing assessments.

How the Midwest premium aluminum CFTC review fits the current price stack
The North American formula has two parts, and both are high at the same time. On the LME side, AL Circle reported a cash offer of USD 3,223.5/t on November 11, up 2.76%. The three-month bid was USD 3,062/t. Opening stocks stood at 226,850 t. Meanwhile, cancelled warrants rose 5.17% to 20,325 t. The same report says LME inventories have fallen 56% in 2026, to their lowest level since 1990 (AL Circle).
Physical supply explains part of that tightness. For example, Wood Mackenzie estimates that attacks in the Middle East removed almost 2% of global primary output. The affected EGA smelter runs at 61% and targets full production in the first quarter of 2027. Morgan Stanley projects a 1.1 Mt deficit in 2026 and an 830,000 t surplus in 2027 (Discovery Alert). Those are third-party projections, and they show how wide the range of outcomes is.
On the premium side, Argus data cited by Discovery Alert shows the Midwest premium rising from USD 0.55/lb on June 4, 2025 to USD 1.12/lb. It set a record of USD 1.19/lb in late May 2026 (Discovery Alert).
Separating the benchmark from the scarcity
The first analytical step is to keep the two questions apart. A change in how the market discovers the premium would not add metal to the market. Likewise, a smelter restart would not change how anyone assesses the premium. The table below maps each cost component to the force behind it.
| Component | Main drivers cited in the sources | Touched by the CFTC review? |
|---|---|---|
| LME price | Global supply, LME stocks, smelter outages | Not directly |
| Midwest premium | Tariffs, storage, logistics, financing, market structure | Yes: price discovery and a possible US physical-delivery contract |
| Scrap and UBC prices | Indexed as a share of the Midwest transaction price | Possibly: a recycled aluminum derivatives market |
| Section 232 tariff | US trade policy | No, it runs on a separate track |
Why the review also reaches scrap and recycled aluminum
The Midwest premium does not stop at primary metal. US scrap often trades as a percentage of the Midwest transaction price (MWTP). Argus figures cited by Discovery Alert track the buying spread for used beverage cans (UBC). It fell from 80.8% of MWTP in January 2025 to 45.3% in November 2025. Annual UBC contracts settled at 55% to 62% of MWTP (Discovery Alert).
That link explains why a recycled aluminum contract appeared in Selig’s speech. When scrap hangs on a primary benchmark, a jump in the premium moves scrap values even if scrap supply has not changed. As a result, a buyer comparing primary and secondary metal may find that both prices share the same reference. This matters for anyone moving scrap between Mexico and the US.
Price is only one side of that choice. A switch in feedstock still has to deliver the alloy and temper the part requires, as our guide to T5 and T6 heat treatment explains.

Two levers on the same cost: Section 232 and benchmark reform
The US applies a 50% tariff on Mexican aluminum and steel under Section 232. Marcelo Ebrard said “We’ve already provided them with all the technical elements” and expects a US decision in the coming weeks. There is no confirmed date (AL Circle).
The tariff is one of the costs the premium absorbs. However, a trade deal and a benchmark reform act through different channels. A tariff agreement changes the cost of moving metal across the border. In contrast, a benchmark reform changes how the market measures the premium. Neither the tariff talks nor the Midwest premium aluminum CFTC review has a date, so the useful exercise is to map scenarios rather than pick one:
- Neither moves. The LME-plus-Midwest formula stays as it is, and the drivers in the table above keep setting the cost.
- Tariff relief for Mexico, no benchmark change. The cost of Mexican metal entering the US changes. The Midwest assessment remains a separate question.
- Benchmark reform, no tariff relief. A new US contract or methodology could coexist with current assessments. Therefore, transition terms in existing contracts would matter.
- Both move. Two variables in the same price change at once, and each one would need separate tracking in every quote.
What buyers in Mexico can do with the Midwest premium review now
None of this calls for a market view. It calls for cleaner contracts and quotes. These are the points a procurement team can check before negotiating 2027 volumes:
- Read the price clause. Identify which premium assessment the contract names, who publishes it, and what happens if the methodology changes or a new US benchmark appears.
- Break every quote into components. LME, premium, freight and duty should appear as separate lines, so each lever stays visible.
- Check scrap references. If you buy or sell scrap, confirm whether your contracts index to MWTP and how.
- Follow primary sources. Track CFTC statements directly, because the review is still at the stage of a chairman’s remarks.
- Compare materials on delivered cost. If you also weigh substitutes, our comparison of aluminum vs stainless steel covers the trade-offs.
Allinx quotes material delivered to destination and analyzes origin and applicable tariff for each order. Sourcing runs on BiiSmart Group’s own logistics and customs capacity, including its team in Shenzhen. We do not quote future prices. We show the components behind today’s price.
This article describes regulatory and market developments. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hedge, and it is not a price forecast.
Technical notes on aluminum and metallurgical materials, in your inbox
New Insights articles on melt treatment, alloys, sourcing and logistics. Unsubscribe anytime.